Narrator 1 – Gracie Jackson

Narrator 2 – Jonah Hutton

Narrator 3 – Molly Jackson

Narrator 4 – Kenzie Prewitt

Mary – Brandy Maddox

Angel – Alice Webster

Angel 2 – Kylee Nichols

Angel 3 – Caitlyn Nichols

Angel 4 – Kailee Law

Elizabeth – Chloe Hart

Zachariah – Kam Chappell

Townsperson 1 – Hallie Mason

Townsperson 2 – Grace Newman

Townsperson 3 – Renae Goodsell

Joseph – Kam Chappell

Shepherd 1 – Nick Hester

Shepherd 2 – Emily Evans

Shepherd 3 – Abby Shireman

Shepherd 4 – Elliana Walden

Shepherd 5 – Lily McEvers

Herod – Alex Tinkman

Advisor – Masen Johnson

Wiseman 1 – Carson Cole

Wiseman 2 – Keegan Newman

Wiseman 3 – Nate Doyle